Adding a link that I found interesting . Quite dry too, usually my skin sweetens stuff up but this is dry all the way. In select stores, the full complement of Milk (its personal, expressive and bold versions) will be carried. That's okay though because it smells great. I bought the sample pack of Commodity colognes when they ran their Kickstarter campaign. Actually, thats true for a lot of scents I like. (Manufacturing, packaging, branding, etc. This is how I picture my stack of student loans smell. I almost like this, except that I can't help but associate the combination of cucumbers with the other notes to pickles. Initially founded in 2013 by Yo Santosa and Owen Gee, the brains behind branding and design agencyFerroconcrete, Commodity is boosting its profile again (it was previously stocked by Space NK and Nordstrom along with Sephora) as beauty industry insiders are eyeing the market for the next Byredo, a brand that went from being a small business to worthy of a big exit in 16 years. Its official description lists top notes of cedar, rosewood, eucalyptus and bergamot; heart notes of cypress, amyris and amber; and base notes of musk, sandalwood and velvet. Does it remind me of LE LABO santal 33 this is a 90 percent equivalent at a cheaper yet not cheap smelling. Sillage is moderate. I think theres still a long runway for the niche category to penetrate into the mainstream, he says. Like you, I was unimpressed. Commodity Book is available as $105 (100 ml) or $26 (10 ml) Eau de Parfum at Sephora and the Commodity website. I only put one spray on each wrist, three days ago, and I can still smell it on things. It's made by Dove. It was a nice woody smell that was really woody -- not a floral woody, not an aquatic woody, but legitimately woody. Thanks for the link, Kanuka! 2022 Commodity Inc, & Commodity Fragrances. Replies to my comments Seeing the uber-chic brand being undercut in that manner makes me smile. I think I can like the smell of old books without wanting to smell like them myself. The cucumber adds a bit ofcool sourness? Santal 33 but with a cucumber opening. At first whiff the cucumber, sandalwood, and bergamot are what hit you hardest. Velvet was similar to Replica By The Fireplace. Because, all romantic thoughts aside, books do give off a chemical or musty smell, depending on the age. For example, how does petrol smell? Le Labos Patchouli? Book was launched in 2013. Researchers had analyzed the aromas of books and created a historic book odor wheel to describe the results including notes of grass, vanilla, musty wood, and much more. The cucumber is what makes this so different from everything else. Oh, for me, its definitely the old book smell. perfume travel It evokes the 'feel' of old books and libraries and not necessarily the smell. I wanted to love this as well, however I cannot get that cucumber to burn off. For me its fresh cucumber mixed with other notes. Fragrances in the personal family are depicted with a minus sign, and fragrances in the bold family are depicted with a plus sign. After I read the reviews likening this scent to pickles, all I can smell is pickles and magazines! It does remind me of a book, or even a fresh magazine.. but at the same time you can definitely pick out the cucumber note. We've created Scent Space to give you greater control over the intensity and projection of your scent; over who else experiences your fragrance. Subscribe to followup comments via email. Despite being synthy it does have very recognisable notes of forest and woods. Theres a molecule in decaying book pages thats very similar to vanillin, apparently. Commoditys current bestsellers are the warm gourmand Gold in its expressive version and the creamy, calming Milk in its expressive version. People were saying, Wow, what a simple concept that is long overdue, he says. This is really a great scent if you like Santal 33. Wonderful concept, fun packaging, smart and affordable scents! Yes. Im sure Luca Turin discusses this in one of his reviews. Please read the Terms of Service and Privacy policy. I like androgynous scents, but I find Book to be too masculine for me. Its a hyperbolic impression every aspect of the book from the paper to mustiness to the binding is amplified into something that resembles more of an autonomous perfume. Basically, not much about Book (or Commodity in general) feels new to me, but I suppose I'm not the target consumer. I don't think it is on-point, but rather reminiscent of a book smell - a new book smell, not an old one. Scent Space went a long way in helping people find what they like., In the future, Commodity may continue reimagining the language of fragrance.

The whole concept is just old hat for perfume-obsessives whove been around for a while. It has a warmness to it but I think this scent is good for any season. Don't get this if you want something that smells exactly like an old book, though. Aquatic incense--like dill pickles, spiced, with a bit of wood in the base that makes this smell great and not strange. Any way this has become my new favorite scent. Historically, when consumers say, I dont like this or that fragrance, they are not necessarily referring to the scent, theyre referring to how strong it is, he says. | Deutsch | Espaol | Franais | etina | Italiano | | Polski | Portugus | | | Nederlands | Srpski | Romn | | | | |, Copyrights 2006-2022 Fragrantica.com perfumes magazine - All Rights Reserved - do not copy anything without prior written permission. I'm also noticing thatCommodity's website includes black-and-white photographs of all the perfumers who have created its scents. But if Santal 33 has it, it must be intentional. There are many people in America who say they dont like fragrances, but, in my opinion, its not that they dont like fragrances, its that they dont like strong perfume like their grandmothers perfume. Meh. Well, I'll be all right. I wanted to love it as an alternative to Santal 33 or something similar since I've been into that lately but this wasn't for me. As it dries down, there are more musky and woody notes that come into play and the cucumber takes a seat in the back. Read about this perfume in other languages: Deutsch, Espaol, Franais, etina, Italiano, , Polski, Portugus, , , Nederlands, Srpski, Romn, , , , . When I opened the box, which contained four fragrance samples, I immediately smelled a dirty scent, putrid and mushroomy. I get primarily a celery/cucumber and musky/amber out of it. Ico Design developed icons and graphics to illustrate the Scent Space classifications.

Will update with impressions later (I plan to go to the gym and am curious how my sweat reacts with it!). Just picked up a Ten 10ML travel spray when visiting New York. I was not wearing my coat when I sprayed it, but it spread from my wrists. Many Brands Have Spoken Out In Support Of Abortion Access. Thank you for what you do!! Aroma by Costa Brazil: Candidate For Best Fragrance 2022? "WATCH LIVE: Cleveland Zoo streaming blissfully odorless video of corpse flower blooming", "Take a Look at These Upcoming Olfactory Exhibitions" (perfumerflavorist), "Guerlain raises over 1 million for the protection of bees" (moodiedavitt), "Inter Parfums Reports Record 2022 Second Quarter Net Sales" (perfumerflavorist). They thought they were personal fragrance people, but they were actually bold fragrance people. Literally just like a new book first opened. I don't wear this, but my husband loves it. At a moment in which niche fragrance brands are ascending (Phlur, Abbott and The Phluid Project recently launched at Sephora), Commodity aims to democratize the niche fragrance segment as Americans have done with countless consumer goods, entertainment properties and cultural ideas. This is Santal 33. Note: top image is Books HD [cropped] by Abhi Sharma at flickr; some rights reserved. Commodity has 11 fragrances it places in an Archive collection that havent been classified under the Scent Space system. The American part is particularly important because I think there are a lot of brands that want to associate with New York or Brooklyn or San Francisco, but I love the fact that other parts of the world have historic significance in perfumery, and I would love America to play a part in that and not just New York or Brooklyn or San Francisco.. ), In the Scent Space system, there are three fragrance classifications: Personal describes intimate fragrances noticed only by the wearers and people very close to them. Let me tell you the experience. Since the Scent Space system debuted in October last year, Arslanian reports the reaction to it has been extremely positive. Given my paired bibliophilia and aromaphilia, you'd think I'd fall hard for Book. This is an interesting unisex fragrance that leans masculine. Start your day with Beauty Independents free daily mailing of top headlines in indie beauty, and gain the knowledge to help your business grow. It's very clean and fresh and it doesn't smell like books to me, but it totally DOES smell like the pages of a glossy magazine. It makes me feel like reading myself to sleep and those last moments before I close my eyes and dream of the story. Leave a comment, or read more about commenting at Now Smell This. I for some reason always get rotting orange whenever I smell this. Holy shit this is so close to santel 33 I'm feeling the love bro.

It smells vegetal, crisp, grassy, and slightly herbal, yet its all a tad too chemical smelling to really survive on its own. ), I catch certain phrases that could also apply to Book: "some entangled cedar and sandalwood with a dash of turpentinea weird, but not unpleasant, dill-like notean inexpensive-smelling, candied, slightly floral musk aroma. Beautiful fragrance, but very very poor performance. Top notes are Cucumber, Eucalyptus and Bergamot; middle notes are Artemisia, Amber and Lavender; base notes are Sandalwood, Haitian Vetiver, Guaiac Wood and Tolu Balsam. Online right now: 2,677, Fragrantica in your language: There is something about the way paper breaks down as it ages that produces a woody-vanilla-like effect, apparently. I completely adore this scent. So, howdoes Commodity's Book smell? We tried to change that terminology, too, but we are taking it one step at a time. He adds, Not to say theres anything wrong with a French word, but many people utilize terminology in perfumery just because its been done that way for a long time, and we would like to rethink that in any way we can.. Theres a difference between what they are saying and what they are feeling., To align words capturing fragrances with preferences about them, Ico Design and Commodity came up with the concept of Scent Space, a system of delineating fragrances that replaces the classifications eau de toilette, eau de parfum and extrait de parfum to focus on scent projection. I thought it was so bad Id throw it away rather than give it away as I usually do with samples I dont like; -a scent that bad must be rancid. This really is a great substitute for Santal 33 and is surprisingly similar. I tried the range at Sephora and the very first one I picked up to smell was Book because I have yet to find the perfect book scent. And enjoyable scent that actually kind of; if you think about it, smellslike a library or a book. It's homey and comfortable, and something I can see myself wearing very frequently. yes, you guessed it:Le Labo Santal 33.1 Looking back atKevin's review of Le Labo Santal 33 (from 2011! Not only that, but I can't imagine this scent not pairing well with almost ANYTHING in my collection (if by chance I wore something strong the night before). I really enjoy all your reviews. Just to add, I've found a matching body wash for this. So, I think the more Commodity can express fragrances in a simple way, it will broaden it to a wider audience who will enjoy what it has to offer.. I laughed at your comment I suppose Im not the target consumer, because thats what I had said to myself as soon as I saw the product photo! Cucumber and vetiver with some low-key sweetness. Having smelled a number of book-themed perfumes (and as somebody whose line of work involves reading many, many books), Id say that the opening of Book" is one of the more authentic takes on the book theme that Ive come across. The vetiver, lime and eucalyptus definitely throw it onto the more herbal, cold-water, outdoorsy facet of sandalwood, not the rich warm indoor spicy kind.

I just received a sample of this so this is first impressions only but this scent is absolutely divine. Having worked my way through the entire Commodity collection, Id say that this is one of the more impressive in both its verisimilitude and its creativity, but Im not entirely convinced that its an appealing scent unto itself as its quite weird. Its aesthetic must be a big part of its appeal. As a reviewer below me touched upon, Commodity, unlike Demeter, are in the business of capturing the air of a familiar scent - not the scent itself. Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh. The same name, but a bit different scents. You'd think it's a nation of undiagnosed allergy sufferers but they gave you pecan pie, carrot cakes, and Melissa Mcarthy so you shut up about it. Upon first application I get a blast of cucumber (smells like the cucumber vodka I adore). I agree: no other experience can rival that of reading an actual book.

I love so many of their scents from Whiskey, Gold, Velvet, and Book. My favorite out of the inoffensive American perfumes category. Thats whats in this, along with some dusty galaxolide balsamic notes. Heaven. Filed Under: perfume talk Tagged With: commodity, ketrin leka, wood. At first, it smells like an excellent aftershave, but once the top notes dissipate the warm and more unisex notes arrive. If I presented 20 niche brands to 10 of my friends not in the fragrance industry, I can almost guarantee they havent heard of any of them. 2022 Indie Beauty Media Group LLC. I prefer it to Santal on me--a little less rubbery, a bit more crisp. Instead, it's clean but a little bit woodsy on me, and that cucumber is absolutely prominent. The note pyramid looks pretty accurate, except, like many reviewers, I'm not smelling the lavender either. I was 100% positive Id hate this fragrance when it arrived in my Sephora package yesterday. As soon as I got my nose to the sprayer I was extremely intrigued. I tried the Commodity fitting set and was pretty unimpressed. Press the space key then arrow keys to make a selection.

The Middle East is on the docket for later this year. And I have several of the Imaginary Authors line! The amber becomes more and more apparent as it becomes less peppery. I even feel that way about tuberose and gardeniaI love them in a vase, but not on my skin. For those interested in an old book layering idea, I sprayed vintage Chaps to the middle of the chest and less than a half spritz of the Fantasy the Nice Remix just above the navel, and I got more or less what I would want from this idea. Commodity is also expected to open a standalone store in New York within six months. Americans love clean scents. It's androgynous and a little rough around the edges. Ive skipped trying them in the past, but next time I wander into Sephora I will look for Book. Can see the Santal 33 resemblance for sure. Longevity is really weak--this lasts an hour, maybe an hour and a half on me, even if I douse myself in it. Something like that. Where Do They Stand On Parental Leave. Its funny, I didnt think of Book as being cheap (at least, not the full bottle), but given the prices of Le Labo, its a relative bargain!? Umema: The Perfume That'll Never Be Smelled, Carner Barcelona - the Summer Journey Collection, Jean Paul Gaultier Scandal Pour Homme Le Parfum, Amber and Ambergris are Two Different Notes, Rice Perfumes That Stand Out From the Crowd, Should You Smell Someone Before Talking to Them? And, of course, CB I Hate Perfume, long known for its storytelling approach to fragrance, has offered a scentcalled In the Library since 2005 or so. Nearly identical to Santal 33 down to the overwhelming dill. Plenty of green and fresh nuances, not masculine in my opinion. The salesperson at Sephora touted this as a unisex fragrance and gave me a sample. Not really, for two reasons. I am a librarian and I do try to check out (ha ha) biblio-scents. It's not like Demeter in that it does not attempt to create a photorealistic imitation of common scents. Not sure I'd spring for the full bottle price but the 10ml travel spray works. For some people it seems those other notes makes the cucumber sour and they say "pickles". The Sandalwood I could smell. Musty, a bit mildewy, even, but also dry and somewhat dusty. Lovely refreshing woodsy scent. Scent Space fragrances are priced at $105 to $145 for a 100-ml. Instead, it captures the basic essence and air of the item being portrayed. it is worth every cent. At first spray. I have to see how it smells of the husband before I rule it out completely, though as it is pleasant, just manly on me. Not entirely inaccurate as a book scent. This smells very expensive and reminds me of very chic bookstores - like the Taschen store in Paris. Interesting! Love it, love it & love this juice. On my skin, it doesn't flatter those warm dry woods very well. Posted by Jessica on 8 June 2017 27 Comments. Almost in the tone of fig. To aid with the elevation of American prominence in perfumery, Commodity teamed up with Ico Design, a London agency the brand tapped prior to Europerfumes involvement for a lifestyle push thats been dropped, to reimagine fragrance vernacular in order to convey fragrances to a wide audience. Not on my skin anymore, obviously, but on my coat and scarf. My favorite thing about this scent is that as it dries down throughout the day it becomes sweeter and warmer. That Perfume You Smell Everywhere is Santal 33, Jardins dEcrivains Orlando ~ fragrance review, Scentings Elizabeth Bennet ~ fragrance review, KyotEau: Bottled Memories ~ perfume books, Rgime des Fleurs Chlo Sevigny Little Flower, 100 fragrances every perfumista should try, And 25 more fragrances every perfumista should smell, 50 masculine fragrances every perfumista should try, 26 vintage fragrances every perfumista should try, 25 rose fragrances every perfumista should try, How to make fragrance last through the day, Fragrance concentrations: sorting it all out, On reformulations, or why your favorite perfume doesnt smell like it used to. Don't subscribe Here's our privacy policy, and a handy emoticon chart. Later, I sniffed each sample and realized it was coming from Book. Bold describes evidently noticeable fragrances sported by wearers intent on making their presence known. How could I resist, right? But given that this line has widespread release through Sephora, its worth checking out if you cross paths with it. I'm not sure what happened to this brand, but their final stock is being sold and then it's gone for good.

And almost everything is "too cloying."

Sitemap 9